Goatis — The Anti-Exercise Guy Who Challenges Bryan Johnson’s “More Is Better” Philosophy
Goatis is a anti-exercise YouTuber with almost 200,000 subscribers. He is also a supporter of raw meat and part of the anti-vegan movement. I have mainly watched his review videos of Bryan Johnson, aka the “Don’t Die” king, who believes he is the healthiest man on Earth. Goatis is deeply skeptical of Bryan Johnson’s lack of evidence and what he sees as poor use of medical science when talking about his health journey and giving extensive exercise advice to the world.
What’s refreshing about him is that he argues that exercise is bad for you because it stresses the body. His goal seems to be quite simple: listen to your body. If it needs rest — rest. If it needs to walk — walk. But lifting heavy weights in the gym every day is not one of those things, according to Goatis, nor is any form of extreme training.
“Because every time you try to adapt your body to something unnatural and it is unnatural obviously because you hate it. Only what feels right, comfortable, natural is intuitively good for you”.
He continues:
“And Brian Johnson is no different. Instead of explaining why exercise could be good for you, if you want to believe that, he right away already assumes that it is good for you without even discussing the topic. It’s as if it’s a no-brainer. Whereas in reality, scientifically, exercise is incredibly unhealthy. It shortens your lifespan.You can prove that very easily scientifically, but instead he will talk about some beliefs and all of these people ignore science knowledge.”
In another part of the video, he argues:
“People who work out and exercise complain about joint problems all the time. Do people who don’t exercise complain about any of that? Never. Unless they eat a vegan diet or something, but typically if you eat good food, no. Never. because you’re not stressing your joints. What happens when you stress your joints? You will injure yourself. You will have pain, inflammation because of the stress, bone density. And uh obviously the comment about insulin is impossible to prove. Nothing that he’s saying can be proven anyway.”
Bryan Johnson says in his video:
“In my personal protocol, I train for 6 to 8 hours per week. Each day, I do 30 minutes of strength training, 30 minutes of cardio with mobility, flexibility, and balance work.”
Goatis responds:
“That is horrible. That’s way too much stress. That explains the dark eye circles. They are only caused by stress, nothing else.”
I have to agree with him when I think about the people I know who are extreme gym rats. Sure, they have toned bodies, but they do look very tired in the face, while people I know who do not work out at all often look younger, with fuller skin and a more refreshed appearance. So the whole idea that too much exercise stresses the body is an important and refreshing perspective.
He argues that all types of seeds are toxic and should be avoided, yet he doesn´t explains why. I know that flaxseeds and sunflower seeds can contain certain compounds that may be harmful in large amounts, but not to the point where they should be completely excluded from the diet. It’s all about balance, something Goatis appears to be missing. He was a vegan before but now is anti-veganism and he thinks this type of diet is one of the worst things you can eat. He has a long list of scientific references that he believes prove his claims about exercise and its negative effects. As someone who has worked with medical science professionally, I have to say that many of his arguments come with significant caveats and require a lot of nuance.
Get Let's talk about THIS Youtuber’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Bryan Johnson argues that you should exercise a lot — “the more the better,” as he puts it — which I think is wrong. Goatis has a point here. Excessive exercise is not necessarily good for you, it does stress the body. However, it depends on what type of exercise we’re talking about, your age, your body, how often you train, how long you train, and many other factors.
A concrete example is endurance athletes who run marathons or participate in long-distance cycling events and do so frequently. People who run hard every day or regularly engage in extremely intense workouts do in fact have a higher risk of developing atrial fibrillation. Even sudden cardiac death occurs more often during physical exertion than while someone is simply sitting at home. That is something we cannot ignore.
I even remember from my own experience a boy in my parallel class in high school who collapsed and died after playing football during gym class. He almost certainly had an undiagnosed heart condition, but the reality is that such conditions are not always detected, and sometimes people do not even know they have them.
That is why there is a strong argument for undergoing a thorough cardiac evaluation, including echocardiography and an exercise ECG, before participating in high-intensity sports, especially marathons and similar endurance events. Of course, no examination can eliminate all risk entirely.
Goatis is right about many things… but also wrong about many things, he has a tendency to lump all forms of exercise together and view everything in black-and-white terms. He often argues that almost everything considered healthy is harmful. Sometimes it sounds as if he believes people should simply sit still and eat raw meat all day. That is not how the human body works. We need movement, we need to eat healthy and not too much meat especially not raw, but yes, we also need time for rest and recovery.
At the same time, he makes valid points about how modern exercise culture has become excessive. Overtraining places stress on the body, and when done frequently and intensely, it naturally creates underlying stress and inflammation, especially when recovery is inadequate. That is something people need to understand.
I also think that many doctors are often too quick to tell people that they need to exercise quite intensely every day for it to even count. Walking for 30 minutes a day is often considered “too little” by many physicians. Yet they rarely ask when exercise becomes too much. It is almost as if they themselves believe in Bryan Johnson’s “the more the better” philosophy, which can be quite dangerous for certain groups of people.
Finally, it’s worth mentioning that Goatis does not appear to be a just some controversial figure who simply holds somewhat extreme opinions. There are videos made about him, such as The Carnivore Psycho Who Tried To Murder His Family (Goatis) By the Youtuber Turkey Tom with almost 2 million subscribers. I don’t know much about Goatis personally, but his video’s description states:
“A Runescape-addicted emo teenager who stabbed his classmates. A vegan conspiracy theorist who starved himself and stared at the sun until he had a mental breakdown. A carnivore who bit into animal carcasses at vegan rallies and ate rotten meat on camera. A serial abuser who started a cult in Romania and stole his girlfriend’s passport to keep her from leaving. An attempted murderer who blackmailed a man into throwing acid on his ex-wife and two-year-old son. It’s hard to believe these are all the same man, but this is Sverige, the ultimate Internet psychopath.”
Whether these claims are true or false remains unknown. However, this article is not intended as a defense of him in any way.
In my opinion, based on his older videos, he comes across as a mentally unstable individual, displaying erratic, confrontational, and at times a lot of antisocial behavior. Examples include eating raw meat directly in front of vegan protesters (who even does that?), allegations that he threw acid on an ex-girlfriend (or another woman he was involved with, I don’t know but it´s just terrible), trashing B&B rooms, and other controversial incidents.
He apparently has never held a regular job and instead relies on donations from his followers to support himself. There has been no shortage of criticism directed at him over the years.
At the end of the day, I do not know for sure whether all of these accusations are true. Based on the amount of material available online, they certainly appear plausible. This impression comes not only from the people making the accusations, but also from his own older videos, which portray someone who seems to enjoy shocking his audience and making provocative statements for attention.
He may well be genuinely unstable and dangerous, but it is also possible that the reality is a mixture of exaggerations, falsehoods, and some genuine erratic behavior on his part, combined with the recklessness, immaturity, and destructive behavior he displayed in his younger years, much of which has been preserved online.
What remains important is that people form their own opinions, examine the evidence for themselves, think critically, and avoid blindly trusting YouTubers or treating them as infallible authorities.
My intention in this article was to focus specifically on the debate surrounding Bryan Johnson’s extreme exercise routines and Goatis’ criticisms of them — not on Goatis as a private individual. Sometimes crazy people can also be right in certain cases, and this might be one of those times.
