When Tipping Becomes an Obligation, Where Is the Hospitality?
Tipping culture in the United States and Canada has become a subject of endless debate. During my travels to San Francisco and New York in late September 2026, I encountered default tipping options of 18%, 20%, and 22% on checkout terminals in San Francisco, and 20%, 22%, and 25% in New York, depending on the restaurant. Yet the issue extends beyond rising percentages. It raises a deeper question about the nature of service itself: when tipping becomes an expected obligation rather than a reward for good hospitality, what incentive remains for service to exceed the merely adequate?
In the United States, tipping can feel like an extension of the customer’s financial responsibility. Under federal law, eligible tipped employees can be paid a direct cash wage as low as $2.13 per hour, provided their wages and tips together meet the applicable minimum wage. Although employers remain legally responsible for making up any shortfall, this structure can leave customers feeling responsible for supporting a server’s income, even when the service falls short of customers’ expectations.
For me, however, the issue goes beyond money to me. It concerns the difference between efficiency and hospitality: completing the required tasks is not necessarily the same as taking good care of a guest.
When Fine Dining Falls Short of Expectations
During my trip to New York City, I dined at La Tête d’Or by Daniel, an upscale French steakhouse where we spent around US$190 per person, including the tip. Upon entering, I noticed that the dining room had plenty of staff. When making the online reservation, I mentioned that we were celebrating a birthday, and our server acknowledged the occasion shortly after seating us.
Once we began ordering, however, the service felt hurried. We ordered the lobster bisque, which was presented tableside. As the server poured the soup into the empty bowl, she completed the process in less than five seconds. The soup splashed wasnt poured very cleanly, there are drips on the rim, leaving an untidy finish. In fine dining, details matter. Tableside service should be an opportunity to demonstrate skill, precision, and attention to presentation. At this price point, I expected a more careful performance.
The end of the meal reinforced my impression that the service was focused more on completing tasks than on creating a memorable experience. Because I had mentioned the birthday in our reservation, the waitress brought out our ordered dessert, Chocolat Amer, with a lit candle. She placed it on the table without saying a word and walked away almost immediately. Before I could ask her to take a photograph, she had disappeared. As the candle continued to melt, I asked another staff member for help. He told me to “give him a second.” Ultimately, it was a kind woman at the next table who took our photograph!
None of these incidents was a major failure in isolation. The soup was served, the dessert arrived, and the birthday candle was lit. The basic tasks had been completed, but the thoughtfulness that might have made the occasion special was missing.
The Difference a Thoughtful Gesture Makes
Get Dora Tsang’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
What made this experience more striking was that I had also encountered a very different kind of hospitality in New York. At Naro, a restaurant in Rockefeller Center, a waitress learned that we had travelled from Sydney to New York. She responded with a small but memorable gesture: she brought us a complimentary yuzu sorbet, separate from the dessert we had ordered, with a candle, saying, “Welcome to New York.” It was not something we had requested or expected. She could easily have completed the service by bringing us exactly what we ordered. Instead, she took a moment to acknowledge our journey and make us feel welcome in her city.
I still remember that waitress’s name — Eden.
The sorbet itself was not particularly important in monetary terms. What mattered was that someone had paid attention, recognized an opportunity to make the experience special, and acted on it without being asked.
What Luxury Hospitality Should Really Mean
My birthday celebrations in Sydney and Tokyo earlier this year offered similar experiences. At restaurants in both cities, the team presented a small complimentary dessert with a lit candle, separate from the dessert we had ordered. At Jean-Georges Tokyo, the staff even prepared an additional birthday plate as a thoughtful surprise.
These experiences raise an interesting question about luxury hospitality. What if guests are already too full after the starter and main course to order dessert? Should a birthday simply pass without acknowledgment? A complimentary dessert is certainly not an obligation, and every restaurant has its own way of celebrating special occasions. The important distinction is between efficiency and genuine hospitality. Efficiency means carrying out a task accurately and promptly. Hospitality goes further: it involves reading the situation, noticing details, and responding thoughtfully to the people being served.
The Japanese concept of omotenashi offers a useful perspective on this distinction. Often associated with anticipatory and attentive hospitality, it emphasizes considering guests’ needs, including those they may not express. This does not mean that Japanese service is always superior or that Western service lacks warmth. Rather, it highlights an important dimension of hospitality that can be overlooked when speed and procedural compliance become the dominant measures of performance.
Again, restaurants do not need to provide complimentary items continually to impress customers, nor does every thoughtful interaction have to involve a gift. However, a rushed birthday presentation or carelessly executed tableside service can undermine the experience, especially in fine dining. Customers paying luxury prices are not simply buying expensive ingredients and elaborate dishes. They are also paying for the atmosphere, attention to detail, and sense of occasion that distinguish a special meal from an ordinary one.
Is Tipping Becoming an Obligation Rather Than a Reward?
Two weeks travelling in the US does not mean I understand how an entire country’s hospitality industry operates. Nevertheless, my experiences in New York illustrate that thoughtful hospitality is possible within the same city. It’s not about the nationality, it’s about personality.
This tension is particularly evident in tipping culture, where customers may be prompted to leave substantial gratuities before they have fully assessed the quality of service. When tipping becomes an obligation rather than an expression of appreciation, the relationship between customers and servers can feel increasingly transactional. The problem is not that American service is necessarily too fast, nor that Asian hospitality is inherently more thoughtful. It is that efficiency should support hospitality, not take over it.
A tip should recognize good hospitality, not substitute for it. In fine dining, the difference between simply serving a customer and making a guest feel genuinely welcome may be the most important detail of all.
