Rethinking the Centaur Team: Who’s Really the Brain?
I’ve been using the centaur as one of my go-to metaphors for human-AI collaboration. The idea that human expertise and AI capabilities combine to create something far greater than the sum of their parts.
But I might have been thinking about this backwards. My assumption? Human = brains, AI = powerful tool. A workhorse indeed.
Then I attended Nikhil Pratap Pachhandara of VTT inspiring presentation at FIMA — Forum for Intelligent Machines Ry AI and R&D seminar at Aalto University.
Nikhil’s presentation was about VTT research team developing AI solutions for high-stakes scenarios like remote maintenance of battle helicopters and other applications of AI in field maintenance.
Get Cows Fly Now by Harri Juntunen’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
In their examples, the AI has access to all available technical documentation and can guide human technicians through complex maintenance procedures via a Unity-powered avatar interface. (cf. page 58 in the document below)
In some cases AI leads the process, troubleshoots in real-time, and adapts to unexpected situations. Meanwhile, the human becomes what the AI leverages as the most sophisticated general-purpose tool on the planet. Humans are capable of executing complex tasks flexibly across diverse physical environments. Take our hand-eye coordination, it’s evolutionarily magnificent.
And of course we have our best on the planet cognitive capabilities, but who’s really the centaur’s brain in the AI-maintenance scenario? AI is catching up us on the cognitive side as well, not just crushing numbers.
Maybe it’s time we stop assuming humans are always the strategic thinkers and AI is always the instrument. In many scenarios, AI might be the one with comprehensive knowledge and decision-making capability, while humans bring irreplaceable adaptability and physical intelligence to execute in the real world.
The centaur metaphor still works, but perhaps we need to be more thoughtful about which half humans are playing in different scenarios.
