Why Reading More Books Wasn’t Making Me Smarter
For years, I treated reading like a superpower.
I believed that the more books I consumed, the smarter I would become. So I set aggressive goals: 50 books a year, then 70, sometimes even 100. I powered through bestsellers, classics, business books, and self-help titles. My Goodreads account looked impressive. My shelves were overflowing.
But something strange happened.
Despite all that reading, I didn’t feel any smarter. My conversations weren’t deeper. My thinking wasn’t clearer. I struggled to recall key ideas from books I had finished just months earlier. Worst of all, I rarely applied what I “learned” in real life.
I was consuming knowledge at an industrial scale, yet very little of it was sticking — or changing me.
The Illusion of Learning
Reading more created a dangerous illusion. Every time I finished a book, I felt productive. I got that satisfying dopamine hit of checking it off my list. I could say things like “I read Atomic Habits” or “I just finished Sapiens,” and it made me feel intellectually superior.
But consumption is not the same as learning.
True learning requires friction. It demands that you slow down, wrestle with ideas, question your assumptions, and actually do something with what you’ve read. I was skipping all of that. I was speed-reading, skimming, and rushing to the next book like it was a race.
I had confused volume with value.
What Changed When I Slowed Down
The turning point came when I forced myself to read fewer books — but with much more intention.
Instead of racing through a book in a few days, I started spending weeks on a single title. I took detailed notes. I wrote summaries in my own words. I argued with the author in the margins. Most importantly, I picked one or two ideas from each book and deliberately applied them in my life or work.
Get Shahbaz Liaquat’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The results were surprising:
- I remembered far more of what I read.
- The ideas actually started influencing my decisions and behavior.
- My thinking became sharper and more original because I was connecting concepts across fewer, deeper sources.
A study from the University of California highlighted something similar: people who read slowly retained about 60% more than those who speed-read. The data backed up what I was experiencing firsthand.
Quality Over Quantity
Reading widely around a topic still has value — it exposes you to different perspectives and helps build a more balanced understanding. But breadth without depth is just intellectual tourism.
The books that truly made me smarter weren’t always the most enjoyable or the fastest to finish. In fact, the most valuable ones often felt slow, frustrating, or even annoying at times. They exposed gaps in my knowledge. They challenged my ego. They forced me to confront ideas I didn’t want to accept.
Those are the books worth reading slowly.
A Better Approach to Reading
If you want reading to actually make you smarter, try this instead:
- Read fewer books, but read them deeply.
- Take active notes — not just highlighting, but rewriting ideas in your own words.
- Apply at least one concept from every book you finish.
- Re-read great books. The second (or third) pass often reveals layers you missed the first time.
- Treat books as tools for thinking, not trophies for your shelf.
I still love reading. But I no longer expect books to magically make me smarter just because I finished them. Books open doors. Walking through those doors — doing the uncomfortable work of reflection, application, and integration — is what actually builds intelligence.
The goal isn’t to read more. The goal is to become more.
And sometimes, that means reading less.
