Filling the Legend’s Boots
Who Has the Talent and Longevity to Become Country Music’s Next Legends?
By Ray Johnson
The Question That Still Echoes Through Nashville
More than 40 years ago, George Jones released “Who’s Gonna Fill Their Shoes?,” a song celebrating country music’s greatest artists while asking who would carry their legacy forward. Its message was both a tribute to the legends and a reflection on the future of country music.
The song name-checks icons such as Conway Twitty, Merle Haggard, Waylon Jennings, and Hank Williams. These artists helped define the genre, and their music remains relevant decades after its release.
Now that many of those legends have passed away, the question carries more weight than ever: Who will step into those boots and earn the same stature, respect, and lasting place in country music history?
A Changing Industry, A Different Path to Stardom
The music business has undergone dramatic changes over the past half-century. Listeners have moved from vinyl albums and eight-track tapes to cassettes, CDs, and streaming. Vinyl has made a comeback with younger audiences, although a new-release album that once cost $4.99 in the 1970s can now approach $25.
Social media has also transformed how audiences discover artists. TikTok and other platforms can introduce a singer to millions of people almost overnight. While that opens exciting doors for new talent, follower counts and viral moments don’t necessarily demonstrate an artist’s ability to sustain a career.
I began questioning whether I was losing touch with the pulse of country music when I learned that Zach Bryan, a relative newcomer I knew primarily through “Something in the Orange,” was moving from arenas to stadiums. I wasn’t singling him out; his success simply prompted questions I had begun asking about the industry as a whole.
- Have today’s stars paid their dues, or has marketing changed the rules?
- Does a massive social media following translate into lasting talent?
- Can an artist sustain a career beyond a viral video or a brief moment in the spotlight?
The traditional path to country stardom has changed, too. Playing small-town honky-tonks, visiting radio stations to win airplay, and working the stages of Lower Broadway were once familiar steps toward a Nashville career.
Consider Naomi Judd, who reportedly visited every record label on Music Row hoping to meet an executive. She and Wynonna eventually found enormous success as The Judds. Today, artists can reach audiences through entirely different routes.
To understand where country music might be headed, it helps to look at the movements and performers that shaped the genre along the way.
The 1970s: Traditional Country, Outlaws and Urban Cowboys
The early 1970s belonged to a remarkable collection of artists, including Johnny Cash, Dolly Parton, Loretta Lynn, Lynn Anderson, John Denver, Tammy Wynette and Merle Haggard.
By the middle of the decade, the Outlaw Movement challenged Nashville’s established music industry. Waylon Jennings, Willie Nelson, Jessi Colter and Kris Kristofferson embraced greater creative freedom, taking their music to Texas and recording albums that would become classics.
Before the decade ended, Urban Cowboy brought country music and the Texas two-step into the national spotlight. The film’s soundtrack helped fuel major hits for Mickey Gilley, Anne Murray, and Johnny Lee.
These artists demonstrated that country music could evolve without losing its identity.
The 1980s: Country-Pop, Traditionalism and a Legendary Class of Newcomers
Country-pop dominated the early 1980s, with Alabama, Dolly Parton, Ronnie Milsap and Kenny Rogers selling records and filling concert halls. Waylon Jennings, Willie Nelson and Anne Murray continued to find commercial success.
Then George Jones released “He Stopped Loving Her Today” in 1980, helping revive his career and reaffirm the power of traditional country storytelling. The song would become one of the genre’s most celebrated recordings.
The decade also produced a new generation of stars:
- George Strait and Reba McEntire: Artists whose enduring careers would establish them as country music royalty.
- The Judds and Randy Travis: Performers who helped bring traditional sounds back to the forefront.
- The Class of ’89: Garth Brooks, Alan Jackson, Travis Tritt and Clint Black, who brought a new wave of listeners to country radio.
Clint Black made an immediate impression with “A Better Man” and “Killin’ Time.” Garth Brooks soon became a dominant force through blockbuster album sales, multiple-night concert runs, and enduring songs such as “The Dance,” “If Tomorrow Never Comes,” and “Friends in Low Places.”
Alan Jackson, once an intern at the Grand Ole Opry, emerged as one of Nashville’s most respected singer-songwriters with “Here in the Real World.” Travis Tritt brought a Southern-rock edge to the genre with hits including “T-R-O-U-B-L-E,” “Country Club” and “Help Me Hold On,” along with collaborations with traditionalist Marty Stuart.
The decade showed that a new class of artists could achieve extraordinary commercial success while establishing the foundations of long careers.
The 1990s: The Decade Fans Still Celebrate
For many listeners, the 1990s remain one of country music’s most beloved eras. The decade delivered an extraordinary range of artists, memorable songs and crossover success.
Vince Gill had long been admired in Nashville, but “When I Call Your Name” helped propel him to national prominence in 1990. His career would earn him 18 CMA Awards and dozens of charting country songs.
Get Ray Johnson’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Meanwhile, established stars continued to thrive:
- The superstars: George Strait, Reba McEntire, Garth Brooks, Alan Jackson, Clint Black and Travis Tritt.
- The hitmakers: Brooks & Dunn, Diamond Rio, Steve Wariner and Pam Tillis.
- The rising favorites: Jo Dee Messina, Joe Diffie, Mary Chapin Carpenter, John Michael Montgomery, Trisha Yearwood, Faith Hill, Martina McBride, Toby Keith, Mark Chesnutt and Terri Clark.
Billy Ray Cyrus became a cultural phenomenon with “Achy Breaky Heart,” while his debut album, Some Gave All, sold more than six million copies.
Then came Shania Twain.
Beginning in the mid-1990s, Twain became a country superstar with enormous pop crossover appeal. Songs such as “Any Man of Mine” and “That Don’t Impress Me Much” helped expand her audience. Her success demonstrated that country artists could reach beyond the genre without abandoning their core fans.
By releasing versions of her music tailored to country and pop audiences, Twain helped open doors for future crossover artists.
The 2000s: Traditional Roots Meet Mainstream Pop
Taylor Swift emerged as a new generation of country-pop crossover star
Country music entered the new century with stars such as Kenny Chesney, Brad Paisley, Tim McGraw and Alison Krauss continuing to draw audiences.
At the same time, Taylor Swift, Carrie Underwood, Rascal Flatts and Keith Urban helped balance traditional country influences with increasingly pop-oriented sounds.
The result was a commercially powerful era. Superstar tours attracted huge crowds, album sales surged and country music strengthened its position as one of the most financially successful genres.
The expanding audience also raised a familiar question: How much could the music change while remaining recognizably country?
The 2010s: Crossover Success and Artists Who Challenged the Rules
The 2010s brought another wave of mainstream success, with Luke Bryan emerging as one of the decade’s most prominent stars.
Few moments captured country music’s crossover power better than Chris Stapleton’s performance with Justin Timberlake at the 2015 CMA Awards. Their rendition of “Tennessee Whiskey” became a defining awards-show moment, and the song surged in popularity afterward.
Stapleton’s subsequent success demonstrated the commercial power of a distinctive voice and a roots-oriented sound.
Other artists continued pushing boundaries in their own ways:
- Miranda Lambert paired fiery performances, including “Kerosene,” with emotionally resonant songs such as “The House That Built Me.”
- Eric Church embraced a renegade persona that recalled the independence of the Outlaw Movement.
- Kacey Musgraves challenged expectations through incisive songwriting, an innovative sound and lyrics that pushed beyond traditional country conventions.
These artists proved that innovation and individuality could coexist with country music’s storytelling traditions.
The Mid-2010s Into the Early 2020s: The Bro-Country Debate
One of the most divisive trends in recent country music was the rise of what became known as bro-country. The term was popularized by journalist Jody Rosen in New York magazine to describe songs such as Florida Georgia Line’s “Cruise” and Blake Shelton’s “Boys ’Round Here.”
Luke Bryan, Blake Shelton and Jason Aldean were among the prominent artists associated with the sound, which incorporated elements of hip-hop, hard rock and electronica music.
Its familiar themes included pickup trucks, back roads, blue jeans, boots, partying and romantic pursuits. For some listeners, the formula represented an exciting evolution of country music. For others, it signaled a departure from the genre’s traditional storytelling and emotional depth.
The debate exposed a growing divide between generations of artists, songwriters, critics and fans. It also underscored the challenge country music has always faced: balancing commercial trends with the qualities that give the genre its identity.
So, Who Will Fill Those Boots?
After more than half a century of musical movements and changing sounds, George Jones’ question remains relevant.
Some contemporary artists appear more focused on social media visibility and headlines than on building a lasting musical legacy. But it would be unfair to suggest that an entire generation lacks talent or ambition. Every era has produced artists who challenged expectations, and some of today’s performers may ultimately prove just as enduring as their predecessors.
There is little debate that Garth Brooks, Alan Jackson, Vince Gill, Reba McEntire and George Strait have secured their places among country music’s legends. Their names evoke memorable songs, exceptional musicianship and careers built over decades.
Their legacies also remind us of a time when Nashville’s music community seemed less divided by political affiliations and public feuds. Today, a single comment can be taken out of context and amplified across social media, sometimes creating conflicts between artists and their fiercely loyal fan bases.
Perhaps the next generation will never fill the boots of the artists who came before them. No one can truly replace George Jones, Johnny Cash, Patsy Cline or Dolly Parton.
But they can follow the footprints.
The future of country music depends on artists who understand its history, respect those who paved the way and have the courage to develop their own voices. Stardom may come through a viral video, a radio hit or a sold-out stadium, but a lasting legacy requires something more.
The question is not whether tomorrow’s stars will sound exactly like yesterday’s legends. It is whether they will create music that matters long after the spotlight fades.
Who will become the next leaders of country music — and which artists will earn their place in its folklore?
Only time will tell.
