Four Persistent Myths About Deaf Children — And What Actually Helps
Editor’s Note: A version of this piece originally appeared in my ebook, That Deaf Kid. Revisiting it now, I can still see how these myths continue to shape decisions being made today. So I’ve updated and re-released it with what I wish more people understood earlier.
There are a lot of myths about deaf people floating around out there. Some are outdated. Some are misinformed.
And some are so absurd they’d be funny — if they weren’t still shaping real decisions about real kids.
So let’s bust a few.
Myth #1: Deaf kids should be kept separate from other deaf kids
Yes, this is still a thing.
We live in a world that celebrates diversity — at least until it comes to deaf children. Then suddenly, there’s this strange urge to separate them based on communication choices. Kids who sign over here. Kids with cochlear implants over there. As if they’re going to influence each other in dangerous ways.
Some people genuinely believe that if Deaf Kid One communicates this way and Deaf Kid Two communicates that way, they’ll screw each other up if they interact.
Um, no. they’re already isolated enough as it is in a world that just doesn’t get it. Misguided attempts at protecting them from each other only makes the isolation much worse.
Deaf kids benefit enormously from meeting other deaf people, especially those with different backgrounds and communication styles. It gives them something critical:
Perspective.
They learn there’s more than one way to succeed. More than one way to communicate. More than one way to exist in the world.
And maybe most importantly — they stop being the only one.
The fact remains that in most mainstream settings, no matter how many supports are in place, a solitary deaf child is still “That Deaf Kid.”
That label doesn’t disappear just because you have an interpreter or an assistive device.
It disappears when you have peers.
Myth #2: Sign language will hurt your English
No.
Let’s fix that sentence:
Lack of language will hurt your English.
The brain doesn’t care how language comes in. It just wants language — early, consistent, accessible. It’s brain fuel.
When deaf kids struggle with reading and writing, it’s not because they learned sign language.
It’s because they didn’t have full access to language during their critical early years.
Meanwhile, hearing parents all over the world are teaching their hearing babies sign language because it accelerates communication. They know that babies have the ability to communicate via sign language before their vocal cords fully develop. Grabbing this opportunity provides a linguistic head start.
Think about that for a second.
We eagerly give hearing kids this advantage…
…and hesitate to give it to deaf kids, who need accessible language the most.
Case in point: When Kobe Bryant was six years old, he moved to Italy when his father, Joe Bryant, joined an Italian pro basketball team. Kobe wound up speaking fluent Italian. At no point did anyone protest, “Hey! Don’t let him learn Italian! It’ll mess up his English!”
As far as I could tell, Kobe never forgot how to speak English. And he also went on to speak fluent Spanish. I would love to see deaf kids get the same opportunity for language enrichment all across the board.
Myth #3: Deaf children with cochlear implants shouldn’t learn sign language
This one sounds authoritative. It’s often delivered with confidence.
It’s also wrong.
Cochlear implants are tools, not magic. They help, but they don’t capture everything. There will always be gaps.
Sign language helps fill those gaps.
There’s research backing this up. Kids exposed to sign language before and alongside spoken language often develop stronger overall language skills.
But instead of throwing more research at you, let me tell you a story.
When I was a kid, I was hard of hearing. One of my best friends, Donny, had a sister who loved yelling at him.
Her favorite line?
“What’s your problem?”
Only I didn’t hear that.
I heard:
“What’s your blblm?”
Over and over again.
“Blblm” was a mystery. The sounds in that word — p, b, m — look identical on the lips. I had no clue what she was saying.
Get Mark Drolsbaugh’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Then one day, when my deaf parents took me along with them to a deaf club, I saw two women signing. One of them signed:
“What’s your problem?”
I froze.
The phrase suddenly had context and meaning.
I asked what that sign meant. They fingerspelled it: P-R-O-B-L-E-M. The light bulb in my head turned on.
The next day, Donny’s sister came bursting through the door again.
“What’s your problem?”
And this time?
I got it. I literally heard it. Completely. Instantly.
Not because my hearing changed.
Because my brain had been given access.
That’s what sign language does. It fills in the blanks. It wires meaning.
That’s not interference, that’s connection.
Myth #4: If your child connects with the deaf community, you’ll “lose” them
This one always makes me laugh.
There’s this quiet fear that if deaf kids spend time with other deaf people, they’ll disappear into some parallel universe and never return.
Let me offer a real-world example.
My wife and I are deaf. We’re active in the deaf community.
We’ve raised hearing kids.
We’ve sent them to hearing schools every day.
And somehow…
they kept coming back.
We threw them out every morning at 7:00, and they returned home at 3:00 like clockwork.
We didn’t lose them to the hearing world.
They gained experiences, friendships, stories — and then brought all of that back home.
Funny how that works.
Now let’s flip that.
When one of our children — who is deaf — was struggling in a mainstream setting, we made a change.
We placed him in a deaf school.
And here’s what we “lost”:
A frustrated, disconnected kid who came home saying school was “meh.”
Here’s what we gained:
A confident kid who talked about friends, activities, and actually enjoyed school.
That’s not a loss by any means. It’s a win. Big time. There’s a reason insiders in the deaf community actually call it Deaf Gain.
All right, let’s wrap this up.
Putting all of this together, we have to ask: What’s really going on here?
Most of these myths come from the same place:
Fear.
Fear of the unknown. Fear of losing connection. Fear of making the wrong choice.
But here’s the reality:
Connection to the deaf community doesn’t take anything away.
It adds.
It adds language. It adds a healthy understanding of one’s true identity. It adds confidence and a much-needed sense of belonging.
And when deaf kids have access to both worlds, deaf and hearing?
They navigate the hearing world in a much more authentic way.
And that, my friends, is one of the reasons they call it Deaf Gain.
